Finding out that your husband or wife has been unfaithful isn’t just a time of profound heartbreak and shock, it’s also a time of intense confusion. There are so many unanswered questions and so many overwhelming emotions.
Most unfaithful partners are deeply committed to saving their marriage. They are honest, forthcoming with information and willing to do whatever it takes, for as long as it takes, to help heal the heart they have broken. They’ll answer questions put to them. They’ll acknowledge what they’ve done and how it’s hurt their partner. They’ll show true remorse. They’ll have patience with their emotional spouse. They’ll end the affair and cut all contact with the other person, and they’ll be transparent with their phone, whereabouts and so on to help regain their partner’s love and trust.
Unfortunately, not all unfaithful partners will react with honesty, humility or empathy when their betrayal is discovered. Not all will work collaboratively with their spouse to rebuild the marriage. These folks aren’t focused on the marriage – they’re focused on themselves and how they can get through this with the least amount of drama and personal inconvenience.
What follows are ten things an insincere spouse would prefer you didn’t know:
1. They are fully aware their actions were a betrayal. Their attempts to deny, deflect or downplay their actions, or to draw you into a debate (i.e. “I just sent him a naked picture, I didn’t sleep with him!” or “Texting isn’t cheating!”), are simply their way to muddy the waters so you cannot see the situation clearly.
2. There’s more to the story than they’ve told you. Statements like, “It was only one time,” or “We never met in person” or “We always used a condom,” are often misleading. It is very common for extra information and revelations to trickle in after the affair or indiscretion is first discovered.
3. They enjoyed having all the power. Infidelity is in many ways a power imbalance in the marriage. The person who is being unfaithful has the power. They know the secret. They can choose whether to end it, continue it or reveal it. And like any kind of power, it can be intoxicating – and a lot of fun.
4. Their phone is proof of guilt. When they accuse you of being “paranoid” or “controlling” when you ask to look at their phone, it is because they are hiding something and want you to stop asking. They know that nobody wants to be “that wife” or “that husband” who is meant to feel insecure or controlling, so they use that to their advantage. Remember: those who have nothing to hide hide nothing.
5. They’re doing their best to pin it on you. Their attempts to transfer blame onto you (i.e. “I wouldn’t have had to have sex with her if you’d be more available!” or “I wouldn’t have had to turn to him if you’d just talk to me once in a while”) are deflections meant to take the spotlight off their behavior. Yes, pre-existing marriage problems may have factored into the infidelity; however, there were other options available to your partner. He or she did not have to secretively become emotionally or sexually intimate with this other person. Only they are to blame for that choice.
6. They want you to stop whining about it. Their impatience with your questions or pain, or their statements like, “Get over it already!” or “I already said I was sorry, what else do you want from me?!” usually mean that they are unwilling to invest the time, energy and emotion into regaining your trust and affection. Translation: they want you to shut up about it so they can watch the game in peace.
7. They made a choice to do it. There’s no such thing as “It just happened.” Similarly, a spouse who says, “It’s impossible to be with just one person!” isn’t addressing their betrayal, they are trying to justify it. The truth is, many couples have enjoyed long-term, devoted, loving marriages. It may not always be easy, but it comes down to personal choice and how you want to live your life.
8. They are not trustworthy. No matter how many times they say, “You have to trust me,” you do not and should not. A spouse who has engaged in any kind of secretive behavior – whether it’s sexual or financial – is not trustworthy. They can regain your trust; however, this is done through actions, not words.
9. It may not be the last (or first) time. While it isn’t necessarily true that “once a cheater, always a cheater,” it is often true that infidelity can become a pattern in marriage on the part of one or both spouses.
10. They know exactly why they did it. A spouse who answers the question, “Why did you do it?” by saying, “I don’t know,” isn’t telling the truth. The truth may be “deep” (i.e. “I thought I was in love with him/her”) or it may be “shallow” (i.e. “It was fun and I didn’t think I’d get caught”) but either way, they know exactly why they did it.
It’s worth mentioning that even motivated spouses can and do show elements of these behaviors. For example, a sincere spouse may say “I don’t know why I did it” to avoid further hurting their partner. A sincere spouse may try to downplay their actions to try and stabilize the situation.
Nonetheless, these ten points should be red flags to you if your partner has been unfaithful, particularly if they are prolonged or delivered with a belligerent attitude. These behaviors often mark the difference between a spouse who wants to save their marriage and a spouse who just wants to save themselves.
Of course, infidelity is complex. One article cannot comprehensively cover all the ways a “difficult” spouse may react to being found out. If you’re facing an episode of broken trust in your marriage, my Overcoming Infidelity // For Betrayed Spouses on-demand audio/video crash course can show you how to manage the infidelity itself, as well as these kinds of higher-conflict behaviors on the part of an unfaithful spouse. There are ways to motivate them to sincerely recommit to you. So don’t be fooled by their behavior. At the same time, don’t give up on your marriage without giving it all you have.